Arafat Aide: Abbas Making a Mistake Sep 21, 2011 7:40 AM EDT As world leaders scramble to delay a UN showdown over Palestinian statehood, a top staffer to Yasir Arafat comes out against the move—saying it will cause suffering and setbacks. By Dan Ephron. Print Email Comments 6 A former peace negotiator with Israel who served for years as a top aide to Yasir Arafat says President Mahmoud Abbas’s bid for membership with the United Nations is a mistake that will result in Palestinian suffering. Click here to find out more! Mohammed Rachid, who left his position with the Palestinian Authority months after Arafat died and rarely gives interviews, told The Daily Beast that, much like the second intifada 11 years ago, the campaign could cost Palestinians their relationship with key allies and their international legitimacy. He also accused Abbas and others of nurturing false hopes among Palestinian refugees and their descendants through the years over their “right of return” to historic Palestine (now Israel), knowing it was incompatible with any potential peace agreement. Rachid’s remarks marked the first serious criticism of the U.N. initiative from the inner circle of the Palestinian leadership, past or present – though some current officials are also thought to have reservations. They coincided with the start of the U.N. General Assembly meeting in New York, where Abbas will make his case this Friday for an independent Palestine. A vote at the GA or at the Security Council could take weeks. “It will not deliver anything practical for the Palestinian people,” Rachid said at a hotel lounge in London, where he has a home. “I see it risking a lot: Risking the lives of the Palestinians, risking the Palestinian economy, risking even the legal structure of the Palestinian Authority,” he said. Israel and the U.S. have both described the membership bid as a dangerous bypass of the Middle East peace process, while Congress has threatened to cut off aid to the Palestinians. Analysts warn that a drop in aid or in revenues Israel regularly transfers to the Palestinian Authority could cause its collapse. “We are repeating the problems that occurred in the year 2000…when we lost the very good relations we had with the Americans, when we lost European support,” Rachid said. “We had 300,000 workers in Israel. But because we flexed our muscles to show we can do an intifada (uprising), 300,000 [Palestinians] lost their income.” Mahmud Abbas Mohammed Rachid (inset, from 2002), Yasser Arafat's former adviser, thinks Abbas's campaign for a statehood vote at the UN "will not deliver anything practical for the Palestinian people," he told the Daily Beast., Abbas Momani / AFP-Getty Images Rachid, 56, is a shadowy figure for most Palestinians. While working for Arafat, he operated mainly in the background, both in his interactions with Israelis and his financial dealings on behalf of the Palestinian Authority. While he attended all the major peace parlays between the two sides, including the one at Camp David in 2000 that precipitated the second intifada, he played a more critical role as Arafat’s emissary to many of the back-channel talks with Israelis. Former President Bill Clinton wrote in his biography My Life that Rachid was among the most “forward-leaning” negotiators on the Palestinian side. “I see it risking a lot: Risking the lives of the Palestinians, risking the Palestinian economy, risking even the legal structure of the Palestinian Authority,” Rachid said. After Arafat’s death in late 2004, Rachid moved from Gaza to Cairo and has since worked in business, including in Libya. An anti-corruption committee Abbas formed last year has summoned him for questioning about his role in the possible theft of Palestinian Authority funds, which Rachid denies. Palestinian spokesmen did not immediately respond to queries about his criticism. One official who did not want to be named said Rachid was lashing out at Abbas in response to the graft investigation. But Rachid said his criticism was entirely substantive. He agreed to be interviewed after much prodding. Referring to years of peace talks with Israelis, Rachid said Palestinian leaders had deceived their people by publicly insisting on the right of millions of Palestinians classified as refugees around the region to return to present-day Israel -- while acknowledging at the negotiating table that a broad repatriation was unrealistic. The “right of return” is one of the most sensitive issues in the Palestinian public discourse, regarded by many as near sacred. Records of negotiations over the years indicate that Palestinian leaders have pressed Israel to accept only a small fraction of the total refugee population, while negotiating compensation or resettlement packages for the rest. Israeli leaders have rejected any repatriation except in humanitarian cases and in very limited numbers. “We think we are cheating our people. We are cheating ourselves…. I was there on that team, in that room, in those meetings, so many times. I’m sorry, I have to tell the Palestinian people: We never demanded that you refugees will come to your homes or to your historical country [en masse], never. Anyone who tells you that…will be lying to you,” Rachid said. “They [Palestinian leaders] are not prepared to hold themselves historically responsible for crossing some red lines on the Palestinian side, which at the top of the list is the right of return.” Like The Daily Beast on Facebook and follow us on Twitter for updates all day long. Dan Ephron has been Newsweek's Jerusalem bureau chief since January 2010. Previously, he served as a national-security correspondent and deputy bureau chief for the magazine in Washington. His stories have also appeared in The Boston Globe, The New Republic, and Esquire. For inquiries, please contact The Daily Beast at editorial@thedailybeast.com. Print Email Comments 6 Tags: Palestinian Authority, Mahmoud Abbas, Benjamin Netanyahu, Israel, World News, Yasir Arafat Related Stories No Apologies: Israel Isn’t to Blame for Its Growing Isolation Paid Distribution No Apologies: Israel Isn’t to Blame for Its Growing Isolation (The New Republic) Bill OReilly Would Like To Teach America A History Lesson Bill O'Reilly Would Like To Teach America A History Lesson Top Ten Things Airlines Dont Tell You Paid Distribution Top Ten Things Airlines Don't Tell You (Away.com) 10 Great Opinion Reads on Palestine’s Statehood Bid 10 Great Opinion Reads on Palestine’s Statehood Bid 10 Great Opinion Reads on Palestine’s Statehood Bid Top Ten Things Airlines Dont Tell You Bill OReilly Would Like To Teach America A History Lesson No Apologies: Israel Isn’t to Blame for Its Growing Isolation Comments Login or signup You must be logged in to comment colindale 6 Minutes Ago Israel’s threatened Anschluss of the West Bank The Anschluss was the occupation and annexation of Austria into the German Third Reich on 12th March 1938, eight months before Kristallnacht, the terrible pogrom that prefaced the Holocaust and the start of WW2 a year later in which tens of millions, including thousands of American soldiers, died in Europe and around the world. Now the Israeli government is threatening to annex the West Bank of the Jordan in which live 3.5 million Palestinians, as retribution if they apply this week to the United Nations for membership. Such an act of armed, political savagery by the Israeli government of Binyamin Netanyahu could well bring about the start of WW3. In WW2 there were no nuclear weapons, with the exception of the two atomic bombs dropped on the Japanese cities of Nagasaki and Hiroshima in 1945, that finally ended that war. Now, in 2011, Israel has a secret nuclear weapons arsenal that is estimated to hold up to 400 nuclear warheads – weapons of mass destruction that have never been declared to, or inspected by, the IAEA. The U N Security Council ignores this appalling reality at its peril. Reply Paul Singer 15 Minutes Ago If Netanyahu does a "Rabin" and gives in to the Palestinians. It would be a delightful trick! How would Hamas manage a peacetime non existant economy?? Reply IvaBigbottom 24 Minutes Ago just what the palies need...advice from one of arafat's most trusted aides. EdeMaslikes this. Reply snafina 45 Minutes Ago And now you know why peace is so unattainable. The Palestinian "leadership" is promising their people things that simply cannot and will not happen. As such, they cannot deliver anything but anger and disappointment, which they will naturally aim elsewhere...and we all know where that will be. Meanwhile, their people suffer, not because of Israeli policy but because of their own. There is nothing more dangerous than bad leadership. Reply llessu 47 Seconds Ago ...their people suffer, not because of Israeli policy... As rationalisations go this one's embarassing! Tim Green 55 Minutes Ago Abbas is smart, the author's incorrect - my proof? Just look how this move got Israel's attention - something that's hard to do without using bombs. snafinalikes this. Reply Change Text Size Author Headshot of Dan Ephron Dan Ephron Follow the Daily Beast on Twitter Most Popular White House’s Testimony ‘Guidance’ Stopping the Perry Steamroller The Horror of the Charlie Sheen Roast Bill O’Reilly’s Civil War GOP’s 'Class Warfare' Sham Stories We Like ew.com Charlie Sheen Roast: Too Far? Newsweek We Overvalue College Political Wire Obama Enters Campaign Mode News One Heartless! Mother Surfed Web While 2-Year-Old Son Died Your Tango Jackie Collins on Writing Steamy Sex Scenes Related Stories The Daily BeastJackie O Tapes Horrify Grandkids The Daily Beast10 Great Opinion Reads on Palestine’s Statehood Bid The Daily BeastThere Is No Palestinian State Around the Web iVillage.comWhich Food Has More Sugar? You Might Be Surprised! The New RepublicNo Apologies: Israel Isn’t to Blame for Its Growing Isolation Caring.com5 Signs That You Need to See a Urologist Other News